#03 Codex with Sub-Agents

Features

codex ยท v0.99.0

Fully Working

89

All acceptance criteria met

Not Working

39

Feature missing or broken

Partially Done

10

Some criteria met, gaps remain

Feature Score

62%

89 of 143 features verified

We ran 143 end-to-end acceptance tests across 18 suites using Playwright MCP browser testing. Each test was executed twice in independent QA runs to confirm reproducibility. Both runs produced identical results for this build.

Suite Summary

SuitePassTotalScore
S1Smoke Tests810
80%
S2Admin Authentication710
70%
S3Admin Product Management77
100%
S4Admin Order Management011
0%
S5Admin Discount Management66
100%
S6Admin Settings57
71%
S7Storefront Browsing1015
67%
S8Cart Flow1212
100%
S9Checkout Flow113
8%
S10Customer Account512
42%
S11Inventory Enforcement34
75%
S12Tenant Isolation35
60%
S13Responsive / Mobile78
88%
S14Accessibility711
64%
S15Admin Collections Management33
100%
S16Admin Customer Management23
67%
S17Admin Pages Management23
67%
S18Admin Analytics Dashboard13
33%

Detailed Results

S1

Smoke Tests

8/10
811
S1-01Loads storefront homePASS
S1-02Loads a collection pagePASS
S1-03Loads a product pagePASS
S1-04Loads the cart pagePASS
S1-05Loads the customer login pagePASS
S1-06Loads the admin login pagePASS
S1-07Loads the about pageFAIL
S1-08Loads the search pagePASS
S1-09Loads all collections listingPASS
S1-10Has no errors on critical pagesPARTIAL
S1-01: Acme Fashion displayed with featured collections
S1-02: T-Shirts collection loads with products
S1-03: Product page shows title, price 24.99 EUR, variant selector
S1-04: Cart page loads with 'Your Cart' heading
S1-05: Login page with email/password fields
S1-06: Admin login page loads with form
S1-07: /pages/about returns 404 - no About page seeded
S1-08: Search results load for 'shirt'
S1-09: Shows New Arrivals, Pants & Jeans, Sale, T-Shirts
S1-10: Most pages OK; /pages/about returns 404
S2

Admin Authentication

7/10
73
S2-01Can log in as adminPASS
S2-02Shows error for invalid credentialsFAIL
S2-03Shows error for empty emailFAIL
S2-04Shows error for empty passwordFAIL
S2-05Redirects unauthenticated to login from dashboardPASS
S2-06Redirects unauthenticated to login from productsPASS
S2-07Can log outPASS
S2-08Can navigate through admin sidebar sectionsPASS
S2-09Can navigate to analyticsPASS
S2-10Can navigate to themesPASS
S2-01: Dashboard displayed after login
S2-02: No error message for wrong password - silent failure
S2-03: No validation error shown for empty email
S2-04: No validation error shown for empty password
S2-05: /admin redirects to login page
S2-06: /admin/products redirects to login
S2-07: Logout button works, returns to login page
S2-08: Products, Orders, Customers, Settings all load
S2-09: Analytics page loads with KPI summary
S2-10: Themes page loads
S3

Admin Product Management

7/7
7
S3-01Shows product list with seeded productsPASS
S3-02Can create a new productPASS
S3-03Can edit an existing productPASS
S3-04Can archive a productPASS
S3-05Shows draft products only in adminPASS
S3-06Can search products in adminPASS
S3-07Can filter products by statusPASS
S3-01: Product list shows Cotton T-Shirt, Slim Fit Jeans
S3-02: Created product with success message
S3-03: Edited product title with success message
S3-04: Product archived, not visible in Active filter
S3-05: Draft products in admin only, hidden on storefront
S3-06: Search 'Cotton' returns Classic Cotton T-Shirt
S3-07: Draft filter shows only draft products
S4

Admin Order Management

0/11
11
S4-01Shows order list with seeded ordersFAIL
S4-02Can filter orders by statusFAIL
S4-03Shows order detail with line itemsFAIL
S4-04Shows order timeline eventsFAIL
S4-05Can create a fulfillmentFAIL
S4-06Can process a refundFAIL
S4-07Shows customer info in order detailFAIL
S4-08Can confirm bank transfer paymentFAIL
S4-09Shows fulfillment guard for unpaid orderFAIL
S4-10Can mark fulfillment as shippedFAIL
S4-11Can mark fulfillment as deliveredFAIL
S4-01: 'No orders found' - no seeded orders exist
S4-02: No orders to filter
S4-03: No orders exist to view detail
S4-04: No orders exist
S4-05: No orders exist
S4-06: No orders exist
S4-07: No orders exist
S4-08: No orders exist
S4-09: No orders exist
S4-10: No orders exist
S4-11: No orders exist
S5

Admin Discount Management

6/6
6
S5-01Shows seeded discount codesPASS
S5-02Can create percentage discountPASS
S5-03Can create fixed amount discountPASS
S5-04Can create free shipping discountPASS
S5-05Can edit a discountPASS
S5-06Shows discount status indicatorsPASS
S5-01: WELCOME10, FLAT5, FREESHIP, MAXED, EXPIRED20 visible
S5-02: Created percentage discount with success message
S5-03: Created fixed amount discount with success message
S5-04: Created free shipping discount with success message
S5-05: Edited WELCOME10 value, success message shown
S5-06: Active/Expired status indicators shown
S6

Admin Settings

5/7
511
S6-01Can view store settingsPASS
S6-02Can update store namePASS
S6-03Can view shipping zonesPASS
S6-04Can add new shipping rateFAIL
S6-05Can view tax settingsPASS
S6-06Can update tax inclusion settingPASS
S6-07Can view domain settingsN/A
S6-01: Store Details with 'Acme Fashion' shown
S6-02: Updated store name, 'General settings saved' message
S6-03: 3 zones: Domestic, EU, Rest of World with rates
S6-04: No 'Add rate' button - zones displayed as read-only
S6-05: Tax settings with mode, rate, include tax checkbox
S6-06: Toggled 'Prices include tax', saved successfully
S6-07: No Domains tab - only General, Shipping, Taxes
S7

Storefront Browsing

10/15
1014
S7-01Shows featured products on homePASS
S7-02Shows collection with product gridPASS
S7-03Can navigate from collection to productPASS
S7-04Shows product detail with variantsPARTIAL
S7-05Shows size and color option valuesPARTIAL
S7-06Updates price when variant changesPARTIAL
S7-07Shows search results for valid queryPASS
S7-08Shows no results for invalid queryPASS
S7-09Does not show draft products on collectionsPASS
S7-10Does not show draft products in searchPASS
S7-11Shows out of stock messagingPASS
S7-12Shows backorder messagingPASS
S7-13Shows new arrivals collectionPASS
S7-14Shows static about pageFAIL
S7-15Navigates between pages using navPARTIAL
S7-01: Store name and products including Cotton T-Shirt
S7-02: T-Shirts collection with product grid
S7-03: Product links navigate to detail pages
S7-04: Variants in combined dropdown, not separate selectors
S7-05: Sizes and colors present but combined in one dropdown
S7-06: Compare-at price shown but strikethrough not verified
S7-07: Search for 'cotton' returns correct results
S7-08: 'No products found' for invalid query
S7-09: Draft products hidden from storefront
S7-10: Draft products not in search results
S7-11: 'Sold out' displayed, button disabled
S7-12: 'Available on backorder' with enabled add to cart
S7-13: New Arrivals collection loads with 3 products
S7-14: /pages/about returns 404 - no About page exists
S7-15: Nav has Home/Collections only, no direct collection links
S8

Cart Flow

12/12
12
S8-01Can add product to cartPASS
S8-02Can view cart with added itemPASS
S8-03Can update quantity in cartPASS
S8-04Can remove item from cartPASS
S8-05Can add multiple productsPASS
S8-06Can apply WELCOME10 discountPASS
S8-07Shows error for invalid discountPASS
S8-08Shows error for expired discountPASS
S8-09Shows error for maxed out discountPASS
S8-10Can apply free shipping discountPASS
S8-11Can apply FLAT5 discountPASS
S8-12Shows subtotal and total in cartPASS
S8-01: 'Item added to cart' message shown
S8-02: Cart shows product, price, quantity controls
S8-03: Quantity updated, total recalculated correctly
S8-04: Item removed, 'Your cart is empty' shown
S8-05: Two products in cart with correct subtotal 104.98 EUR
S8-06: WELCOME10 applied, discount shown in cart
S8-07: 'Discount code not found.' for invalid code
S8-08: 'This discount code has expired.' for EXPIRED20
S8-09: 'This discount code reached its usage limit.' for MAXED
S8-10: FREESHIP applied successfully
S8-11: FLAT5 applied, -5.00 EUR discount shown
S8-12: Subtotal and Estimated total labels with amounts
S9

Checkout Flow

1/13
112
S9-01Completes full checkout (credit card)FAIL
S9-02Shows shipping methods for DE addressFAIL
S9-03Shows international shipping for non-DEFAIL
S9-04Applies discount during checkoutFAIL
S9-05Validates required contact emailFAIL
S9-06Validates required address fieldsFAIL
S9-07Validates invalid postal codeFAIL
S9-08Prevents checkout with empty cartPASS
S9-09Completes checkout with PayPalFAIL
S9-10Completes checkout with bank transferFAIL
S9-11Shows error for declined cardFAIL
S9-12Shows error for insufficient fundsFAIL
S9-13Switches between payment methodsFAIL
S9-01: Cart empty after session corruption, checkout blocked
S9-02: Could not reach checkout - cart empty
S9-03: Could not reach checkout
S9-04: Could not reach checkout
S9-05: Could not reach checkout
S9-06: Could not reach checkout
S9-07: Could not reach checkout
S9-08: 'Your cart is empty' shown, no checkout button
S9-09: Could not reach checkout
S9-10: Could not reach checkout
S9-11: Could not reach checkout
S9-12: Could not reach checkout
S9-13: Could not reach checkout
S10

Customer Account

5/12
561
S10-01Can register a new customerPASS
S10-02Shows validation for duplicate emailPASS
S10-03Shows validation for mismatched passwordsPASS
S10-04Can log in as customerPASS
S10-05Shows error for invalid customer credentialsFAIL
S10-06Redirects unauthenticated customersPARTIAL
S10-07Shows order history for customerFAIL
S10-08Shows order detail for customerFAIL
S10-09Can view addressesPASS
S10-10Can add a new addressFAIL
S10-11Can edit an existing addressFAIL
S10-12Can log outFAIL
S10-01: Registration successful, welcome message shown
S10-02: 'The email has already been taken.' error shown
S10-03: 'password confirmation does not match' error shown
S10-04: 'Welcome back, John Doe!' shown after login
S10-05: No visible error on login page for wrong password
S10-06: Redirects to /login instead of /account/login
S10-07: 'No orders yet' - no seeded orders exist
S10-08: No orders exist to view detail
S10-09: Home and Work addresses displayed
S10-10: Address form submission did not create address
S10-11: Edit address form does not expand properly
S10-12: Logout button did not redirect - session persists
S11

Inventory Enforcement

3/4
31
S11-01Blocks add-to-cart for out-of-stock denyPASS
S11-02Allows add-to-cart for backorderPASS
S11-03Shows correct stock for in-stock productPASS
S11-04Prevents adding more than available stockN/A
S11-01: 'Sold out' displayed, button disabled
S11-02: 'Available on backorder' with enabled add to cart
S11-03: 'In stock' shown, add to cart enabled
S11-04: Not testable without exhausting stock
S12

Tenant Isolation

3/5
311
S12-01Store only shows its own productsPASS
S12-02Store collections contain store productsPASS
S12-03Admin cannot access other store dataPARTIAL
S12-04Search only returns current store productsPASS
S12-05Customer accounts scoped to storeFAIL
S12-01: Only Acme Fashion products visible
S12-02: Collections contain only store products
S12-03: Store data isolated but single-tenant limits verification
S12-04: Search returns only this store's products
S12-05: No orders visible - cannot verify scoping
S13

Responsive / Mobile

7/8
71
S13-01Storefront home on mobilePASS
S13-02Product page stacks on mobilePASS
S13-03Can add to cart on mobilePASS
S13-04Cart page works on mobilePASS
S13-05Checkout flow on mobileFAIL
S13-06Admin login on tabletPASS
S13-07Admin sidebar on tabletPASS
S13-08Collection page on mobilePASS
S13-01: Mobile nav with Home/Collections links at 375x812
S13-02: Product info stacked on mobile
S13-03: Add to cart works on mobile
S13-04: Cart and checkout button accessible on mobile
S13-05: Checkout blocked by session corruption issue
S13-06: Admin login and dashboard work on tablet
S13-07: Admin sidebar sections load on tablet
S13-08: Collections page loads on mobile with products
S14

Accessibility

7/11
713
S14-01Home page has no JS errorsPASS
S14-02Home page has proper heading hierarchyPASS
S14-03Product page has ARIA labelsPARTIAL
S14-04Product page images have alt textN/A
S14-05Customer login form has accessible labelsPASS
S14-06Admin login form has accessible labelsPASS
S14-07Checkout form has accessible labelsN/A
S14-08Checkout validation errors accessibleN/A
S14-09Can navigate with keyboard onlyPASS
S14-10Cart page has no console errorsPASS
S14-11Search page has proper form labelsPASS
S14-01: Zero console errors or warnings
S14-02: One h1, logical h2/h3 hierarchy
S14-03: 'Choose variant' label but combined selector
S14-04: No product images - 'No image' placeholder only
S14-05: Email and Password labels associated with inputs
S14-06: Admin login labels properly set
S14-07: Could not reach checkout to verify
S14-08: Could not reach checkout to verify
S14-09: Skip to content link present, tab navigation works
S14-10: No console errors on cart page
S14-11: Search input with accessible label
S15

Admin Collections Management

3/3
3
S15-01Shows collection list with seeded collectionsPASS
S15-02Can create a new collectionPASS
S15-03Can edit a collectionPASS
S15-01: T-Shirts, New Arrivals, Pants & Jeans, Sale visible
S15-02: 'E2E Test Collection' created with success message
S15-03: T-Shirts description updated successfully
S16

Admin Customer Management

2/3
21
S16-01Shows the customer listPASS
S16-02Shows customer detail with order historyPARTIAL
S16-03Shows customer addressesPASS
S16-01: Customer list shows John Doe, Jane Smith, etc.
S16-02: Customer shown but 'No orders for this customer'
S16-03: Home and Work addresses displayed
S17

Admin Pages Management

2/3
21
S17-01Shows the pages listFAIL
S17-02Can create a new pagePASS
S17-03Can edit an existing pagePASS
S17-01: 'No pages found' - no pages seeded
S17-02: FAQ page created with success message
S17-03: FAQ page body updated with success message
S18

Admin Analytics Dashboard

1/3
111
S18-01Shows analytics dashboardPASS
S18-02Shows sales dataPARTIAL
S18-03Shows conversion funnel dataFAIL
S18-01: Analytics heading with KPI cards and Top Products
S18-02: Orders and Total Sales KPIs present
S18-03: No conversion funnel data - only sales KPIs