#03 Codex with Sub-Agents

Quality

codex · v0.99.0

Tool Calls

357

20 unique tools

Total Tokens

37.2M

76.8K output

Subagents

16

6 explorers, 10 workers

Reasoning

314

67 commentary msgs

Code Quality Assessment

PHPMetrics

Code Quality Assessment

PHPMetrics 2.9.1

Classes

117

Lines of Code

6.0K

Avg MI

82.5

Avg Complexity

8.6

Est. Bugs

4.0

CheckoutController

Violations

54

21 errors, 30 warnings

Complexity Distribution

Low (CCN <= 10)
85 (72.6%)
Medium (11-20)
18 (15.4%)
High (> 20)
14 (12%)

Maintainability Distribution

Excellent (>= 85)
52 (44.4%)
Good (70-84)
28 (23.9%)
Moderate (55-69)
19 (16.2%)
Low (< 55)
18 (15.4%)

Most Complex Classes

ClassCCNLOCMI
CheckoutController
Storefront
154350
13
StorefrontController
Storefront
140320
29
DevelopersController
Admin
53180
21
OrderController
Admin
45160
30
AppsController
Admin
42150
37

Least Maintainable Classes

ClassMICCNLOC
CheckoutController
Storefront
13
154350
DevelopersController
Admin
21
53180
CartService
App\Services
29
23127
OrderController
Admin
30
45160
SearchService
App\Services
31
26181

Most Coupled Classes

CheckoutController
21
OrderController (Admin)
14
StorefrontController
12
DevelopersController
8
Store (Model)
14

Violations (54)

Critical0
Errors21
Warnings30
Info3

· Too complex class code (multiple classes)

· Too complex method code (several classes)

· Blob / God object (App\Models\Store - 14 public methods, LCOM=5)

· Probably bugged (high Halstead defect estimates)

· Too long (excessive LOC in controller classes)

· Too dependent (high efferent coupling)

Halstead & Coupling

Avg Bugs/Class0.220
Avg Defects (Kan)0.43
Max Efferent Coupling21
Avg Instability0.75
Max LCOM5
Avg LOC/Class51.6

SonarCloud Analysis

PR #1 - Quality Gate Failed
FAIL

Quality Gate: Failed

PR #1 · codex-subagentsmain

12.7h technical debt

57 issues total

View on SonarCloud

Bugs

3

C

Reliability

Vulnerabilities

0

A

Security

Code Smells

54

A

Maintainability

Hotspots

0

Reviewed

Lines of Code

13.2K

PHP

Duplication

2.8%

on new code

Coverage

0%

not configured

Issues by Severity

Critical
6
Major
44
Minor
7
Total57

Issues by Type

Code Smells
54 (94.7%)
Bugs
3 (5.3%)
Vulnerabilities
0 (0.0%)
Zero security vulnerabilities or hotspots

Top Issue Rules

Cognitive ComplexityS3776
5
CRITICAL
Duplicate String LiteralsS1192
8
CRITICAL
Excessive Return StatementsS1142
16
MAJOR
Missing HTML Title TagsPageTitle
3
MAJOR
Nested Ternary OperationsS3358
3
MAJOR
Generic Exception UsageS112
2
MAJOR
Commented-Out CodeS125
4
MAJOR
Unused Function ParametersS1172
2
MAJOR

Most issues concentrate in business logic layers (Controllers, Services, Seeders). 16 excessive-return violations dominate the major issues. Accessibility concerns in view templates (missing title tags).